August 26, 2008
Dog Training Collar
Do Dog Training Collars Work?
Debate is inevitable when the subject of whether the use of electronic dog training collars is a humane way of canine obedience training. But it is useful to gain an understanding of what electronic dog training collars are, and how they function, before taking sides.
There are several different types of dog training collars. Most people are familiar with those that contain a sensor or probe that connects to the dogs skin. When the dog handler presses a button on his control unit, a signal is transmitted to a receiver unit on the collar, and an electric sensation is felt by the dog.
A second type of electronic dog collar emits a high pitched sound that dogs dislike; the third is a citronella collar which squirts citronella (which dogs don't like) in front of their noses.
The type of dog training collar that is chosen is really irrelevant. They all have the same objective, to make the dog associate improper behaviour or response, with an unpleasant sensation, be it an electronic buzz, a sound or an unpleasant smell.
Those who don't approve of electronic dog training collars believe that rewarding a dog for doing the right thing is a better, kinder and more effective training method.
However, there are dogs that are very difficult to train, and electronic dog training collars can be used as an aid to conventional command training. As an example, when you give your dog the "sit" command, a handler would gently push down on the dogs lower back, which makes him sit. After doing this several times, a dog usually catches on, and will sit without the handler touching him. Of course this needs to be repeated often over a period of time to reinforce the lesson.
If at this stage the dog refuses, or ignores the command, the handler might elect to use the electronic dog training collar. Use of the collar will ensure the handler has the dog's attention, and then the command will be given again, with correct response rewarded with a treat.
A great use for electronic dog collars is to train your dog to stay on your property - for his own safety as well as neighbors. Called an "invisible fence" and requires a thin wire to be run around your property boundary (or the back yard - wherever you want your dog to remain). Whenever the dog approaches the wire, a beeping alarm is triggered. If the dog ignores the alarm a low-grade electric shock is then administered.
Electronic dog training collars are a good method of reinforcing verbal commands for difficult to train dogs. However, their use should remain as a reminder to the dog to respond correctly to commands, and never used as a form of punishment.






